Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Sounded really good until I got to the part about needing to pay a subscription fee.


It's ONE DOLLAR per month. ONE DOLLAR! And it's only if you want the extra features. Would you rather have ads be inserted between your songs or something? The development of the app needs to be paid for one way or the other.


One dollar is too much for something that was a solved problem (media sync).


How is that a solved problem?


How is it not?

Plug shit into PC, two way sync. WinPhone and iOS do this fine.


Ah yes, the old "sync 600GB of MP3s onto a 32GB device" trick.


Yes because you really need 600GB of mp3s which on the back of an envelope calculation is over 1000 days of listening for 8 hours a day at a reasonable bitrate with no repeats...

I'm sure, at amazon prices which is a fair approximation including CDs, you didn't spend $100,000 on them either.

This is really not a problem. Well it is but only greed created it.


You miss the point. The idea is not to be able to listen to all music, but any music from one's collection.

Putting this down to greed? What an incredibly short sighted, ignorant thing to say. Perhaps we should have stopped at black & white feature phones because only greed could mean we wanted to access the whole internet on the move?

It isn't a "solved problem" because there are still issues with the solution.


You don't understand: All music must be in FLAC because MP3/AAC/WMP just "doesn't sound right".


I just copy it all over the internet. I can't countenance making multiple trips with a usb key, or even worse lugging around an external hard drive.


Which has to be reason #2 or #3 why I hate iTunes with passion.


You don't need to. Since subsonic is Open Source, there's naturally multiple forks with the licensing code removed. The best fork, which also adds features, is madsonic[0]. I recommend it. In addition, if you already have subsonic, the license code is simply a check if your password = the md5 of your email. So using "[email protected]" and "23463b99b62a72f26ed677cc556c44e8" will make it think you're a valid subscriber and give you all features.

[0]: http://www.madsonic.org/


> the license code is simply a check if your password = the md5 of your email

That used to be the case, but the newer versions actually phone home and verify the license.


Thanks for the information. It was true the last time I used subsonic, but that isn't all that recently. Still, I have no doubt it wouldn't be hard to remove it from the code.


echo "127.0.0.1 subsonic.org" | sudo tee -a /etc/hosts


Sorry but the front of that page made me throw up a bit in my mouth and just close it back down again...


I like how they used a massive picture and then scaled it down in the IMG tag instead of just resizing the picture and putting it on the page. Very entertaining...!


You don't need to. It's a freemium model - paying a subscription gets you some extra features, like apps for mobile.


We all need to eat.


But it seems those music listeners in this thread are the type that prefer a single up-front cost over a recurring subscription.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: