Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's all theoretical, in the same way that our understanding of gravity or radiation itself is theoretical.


It's more like a , you might get killed by a car if you step into the street kind of theoretical. Or the drip of a water clock will fill the container in 8 hours kind of theoretical. Or a don't plant too early or your people will starve kind of theoretical.

A theory in science is a model backed by the huge majority of observational evidence and the collective experience of the model's community. There are no other equivalent human institutions for reliability. None.

So saying "it's just a theory" in the case of uranium-dating is a fairly unreasoned attitude.


I'm not saying it dismissively. "It's a theory" is not a negative thing to say. It does not mean that I doubt it in any way.


By that metric, our understanding of anything is theoretical.


Yep.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: