Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Not really no, you got the support you were willing to pay for.
 help



If the maintainer merely doesn't fix the bug, then yes. If they close the bug report so it gets lost and other contributors are discouraged from working on it, then no.

Closed reports are not lost, they are still searchable/linkable, they are just not in the list of work to do.

This is entirely up to the maintainer, who puts in the work and gives up their time/money to do so. If you want to be in charge on a given repo, put in the work and become a real contributor, if not accept the rules the maintainers choose.


You know what I mean. If the issue is closed, it looks like it's been solved. A new issue may be created that duplicates it, etc.

Obviously it's up to the maintainer. I'm saying what the maintainer should do, not what they can do.


Dupe reports are a signal all by themselves, that's really not harmful, nor does something being closed implied solved.

You shouldn't presume to know what is best for an open source maintainer of any given project - projects vary, reports vary in quality, and the job of maintenance is not an easy one.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: