Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

So you are saying now that you can bypass a lot of solutions offered by a mix of small/large providers by using a single solution from a huge provider, this is the opposite of a centralization of power?


>"by using a single solution from a huge provider"

The parent didn't say that though and clearly didn't mean it.

Smaller SaaS providers have a problem right now. They can't keep up with the big players in terms of features, integrations and aggressive sales tactics. That's why concentration and centralisation is growing.

If a lot of specialised features can be replaced by general purpose AI tools, that could weaken the stranglehold that the biggest Saas players have, especially if those open weights models can be deployed by a large number of smaller service providers or even self hosted or operated locally.

That's the hypothesis I think. I'm not sure it will turn out that way though.

I'm not sure whether the current hyper-competitive situation where we have a lot of good enough open weights models from different sources will continue.

I'm not sure that AI models alone will ever be reliable enough to replace deterministic features.

I'm not sure whether AI doesn't create so many tricky security issues that once again only the biggest players can be trusted to manage them or provide sufficient legal liability protection.


with ai specialized hardware you can run the open source models locally too and without without the huge provider stealing your precious IP


ah, so what you are saying is this: now you can buy your own specialized hardware, which is realistically produced and sold by a single company on earth, compete with ~3 of the largest multinational corporations to do so (consider the ram prices lately, to get a sense of the effect of this competition), spend tens of thousands in the process, and run your 'own' model, which someone spends millions to train and makes it open for some reason (this is not a point about its existence, its about its reliability. I don't think its wise to assume the open models will be roughly in line with SOTA forever). This way, by spending roughly 1-2 orders of magnitude more, you can eliminate a handful of SaaS products that you use.

Sorry, I don't see this happening, at least not for the majority. Even if it does, it would still be arguably centralizing.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: