Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

They can steal Workspaces from Vivaldi.

Or they can steal vertical tabs from Vivaldi.

Or they can steal the built-in RSS client form Vivaldi.

Or they can steal the ability to save sessions from Vivaldi.

Or they can steal the built-in notes from Vivaldi.

Or they can steal the tab stacking from Vivaldi.

Or they can steal the profile switching from Vivaldi.

Honest question. What could Vivaldi "steal" from Firefox?



Containers.

Firefox has this ability to separate cookies etc into different partitions, and users can make use of this feature by opening tabs in different containers. Many times when I use profiles in other browsers what I really want is container tabs.

That combined with sideberry makes Firefox the superior one when I was checking if Vivaldi was worth switching to.


Containers seemed great to me at first but eventually they actually got in my way just as profiles do.

I just ended up with mounds of rules about what to open in the same container vs not, what urls to force in a given container, etc.

I still want to like them, but TBH, I don't miss them in Vivaldi.

Totally willing to accept I was doing containers wrong, I guess, but in that case, I don't know what "right" would've looked like.


That was also my story and I abandoned containers that time. But it turns out to be more about bad default UI.

The game changer is Sideberry. It makes manually managed container tabs almost effortless. Instead of messing with auto rules, you would:

- Set default containers for each pane;

- Use shortcuts to open new sibling/child tab in the same container;

- Save/restore tabs as bookmarks keeping their containers.

It’s still not perfect UI, but in reality covers all the use cases where I’d reach for a container.

It’s just so much peaceful to know that I won’t accidentally tie anything to the google account, while still have gmail open in that cyan backgrounded tab just a ctrl-tab away.


So I'd need an extension from my extension? :)

Maybe I can go back to Zen just to get more layers out of my browser sammich.


> Honest question. What could Vivaldi "steal" from Firefox?

Not being so weirdly buggy on Windows. It's my main browser but man does it have odd behaviors that need restarts occasionally.


> Or they can steal vertical tabs from Vivaldi.

Firefox already has vertical tabs and they work great.

> Or they can steal the profile switching from Vivaldi.

I'm pretty sure that Firefox has profile switching in some capacity, although I don't personally use it and can't vouch for it.

As for the rest of these, I agree completely. Firefox has too many wacky AI experiments and not enough normal browser features.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: