Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Will it ever run in WASM?

EDIT: there is Lumen, but not sure if it's stalled or still going.



Usage

It is not immediately clear what the intended usage pattern for Lumen and WebAssembly is.

Pros and Cons

Things we like:

    The idea of having both runtime and code compile is cool
Things we’re not big fans of:

    We could not immediately figure out exactly how Lumen works, and builds appear to be failing
    The project might be stalled or unmaintained. It has not been updated in over a year.


WebAssembly’s goal is to be a “portable execution layer” — an OS abstraction. If WASM becomes the standard runtime across browsers, servers, and edge networks, something still has to orchestrate thousands of concurrent tasks, message queues, supervisors, restarts, etc.

Erlang/OTP already solves that — beautifully.

So, the motivation is:

“What if BEAM’s concurrency runtime could itself be compiled to WebAssembly — and become the actor system of the WebAssembly world?”

That’s why projects like Firefly and Lumen are interesting: they’re exploring whether Erlang’s runtime model can become part of the WASM ecosystem — just like how Go and Rust shaped the serverless world.


> Will it ever run in WASM?

A ten-second search reveals [0]. (Have Kids These Days forgotten all about Emscripten?) However, given that web browser pages are often short-lived, I don't see what benefit bringing in all of Erlang and its VM gets you, other than the fact that you've pulled off the stunt.

[0] <https://www.antvaset.com/erlang-otp-wasm>


WASM runs on the edge, e.g. in Cloudflare workers (but I mean more generally) .. And it is an emerging compatibility layer




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: