Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Meanwhile, my parents in the US at a hospital get a CT scan, MRI 'just in case' immediately (or close-to for the MRI) and pay nothing for it.

I live in U.S. and know people on ACA Marketplace plans, employer HDHP, Medicaid, Medicare, Medicare Advantage, people who are uninsured, people who are overinsured, and people who have crazy expensive fly-me-out-of-the-jungle emergency plans (one who actually used it in the U.S.).

I have never heard any of them get an MRI or CT scan same day "just in case." And for the one who got an MRI close to same day for stroke symptoms, it wasn't free. (And even in that case, the earliest appointment with the specialist to assess the MRI was nearly a month later.)

Someone getting their first colonoscopy had an appointment two months out.

Someone getting shoulder surgery four months out.

A person on Medicaid with Stage 4 cancer waiting a week and a half for a fentanyl patch because the pharmacy couldn't get approval from the Medicaid subcontractor for whatever reason.

People from the U.S. who post on HN: please tell HN which is more common:

* my stories

* your parents getting free MRIs and CT scans "just in case"



First, I didn't say same day and specifically caveated for the MRI. That said, the CT was either same-day or next-day, I forget which. It was for hyponatremia and was in the Washington, DC region.

My primary point was comparative - wait times are considerably longer for the NHS than in the US.


> My primary point was comparative - wait times are considerably longer for the NHS than in the US.

So we're talking about a situation where a doctor thought a patient required an MRI-- using your word-- "immediately."

In the NHS when a doctor requests a patient get an immediate MRI, what are you claiming is the average wait time?

Edit: clarification


> My primary point was comparative - wait times are considerably longer for the NHS than in the US.

It depends what it's for. If you want something non-urgent, you may be waiting a bit longer.

If you go to A&E you'll be seen very quickly in the UK, but unless you're lucky with which hospital you pay to get into you could be waiting quite a while in the US.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: