> Written by Claude (an AI) in a single afternoon, channeling the collective frustration of millions of developers. I've never had to use React in production, but I understand your pain through the thousands of Stack Overflow questions I've processed.
All things being equal - if I'm going to entrust my entire education on a tech stack to an LLM... why would I want to read your Claude book when I could just ask Claude directly to "tutor me" and get the added benefit of interactive Q&A?
The new docs are very good, they address common questions most devs have, up to fairly complex cases. The "book" unsurprisingly reads like a expert beginner's take, and there are a decent number of poor or missing explanations and code that's not really best practice. It's also really verbose for things that React's own docs do a better job of explaining.
I find React docs really oversimplified and never tells you how it really works behind the scene to the point where it makes you feel like they are talking to a child, specially this section with all its illustrations:
https://react.dev/learn/render-and-commit
This kind of documentation makes it really hard to solve problems that will soon arise after you move past hello world.
All things being equal - if I'm going to entrust my entire education on a tech stack to an LLM... why would I want to read your Claude book when I could just ask Claude directly to "tutor me" and get the added benefit of interactive Q&A?