Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

They consider being anti-zionist to be antisemitic. This one section alone. The remainder is fine but I believe this shows they can't disconnect Israel from Jewishness

"Examples of when such critiques cross into antisemitism include when they ostracize and vilify Zionists and Zionism"

https://www.adl.org/resources/tools-and-strategies/what-anti...



It's perfectly fine to criticize the government of any country. But is anyone in the UK, or Syria, or Iraq (my birthplace) saying those countries don't have a right to exist? Why just Israel?

When you have a standard that exists for one country or people that doesn't exist for anyone else, isn't that the definition of bigotry in all its forms?


There's two levels:

1. Hating someone for an attribute they can't fix or were born with is wrong. For example, skin color, sexual orientation, or being Jewish*

This is wrong because a Black person can't stop being Black, a gay man can't stop being attracted to men. In other words it's not the fault of the person.

2. Hating a person because of a belief is different. Hating all Nazis is bigotry but almost all people wouldn't consider that wrong. Hating all people who think Israel should be a country is also bigotry. The big difference is the person has control over their belief.

> standard

What standard? Who is setting this standard?

#------------ * Being Jewish is considered both an ethnicity and religion, it's complicated. Hitler didn't care if jews converted, his definition was ethnic. In this conversation I'm considering it an ethnicity.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: