Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

When you consider the limited availability of batteries, electric vehicles don't make sense compared to hybrid ones.

Neither make sense compared to halving our speed limits.



β€œFor the first time I can remember, we can access all the supply we need for both businesses.” Martin Viecha, Tesla IR, September 2022

https://electrek.co/2022/09/12/tesla-access-all-the-batterie...


...for Tesla cars. Which are an insignificant part of the world car production.

Do this exercise, pick a workman's work vehicle that has a hybrid version. Make note the mpg difference between the hybrid and regular model. I do mean a workman's vehicle, not a hybrid Versa or the like. A full sized van. A pickup.

Take the Tesla battery pack kWh and divide by the workman's hybrid drivetrain's batt pack. This is how many workman's vehicles could be hybridized with one Tesla.

Look up, make an estimate, the miles a workman drives per year. Do the same for the tesla.

Calculate the fuel burned by one tesla and N regular workman's vehicles and compare that to N hybrid vehicles + one Honda accord.

The scenario with the Tesla ends up burning (much) more gasoline than with the hybrids.

Now multiply that the number of Tesla's made per year.

Is this number high or lower than the number of workman's vehicles made every year?

Note, for simplicity, we haven't even considered far more damaging scenarios involving heavy vehicles doing stop-go all day. Like a municipal van. Or a garbage truck. Or package delivery.

Also note, for simplicity I did not consider the CO2 emission of driving a Tesla. I don't want to get into a "greenified grid" debate.

Teslas are about making rich yuppies keep their cake and eating it too. It makes them feel good, neigh superior, about their over indulgent, over consuming lifestyle. If they truly cared about CO2 they'd be clamoring for lower speed limits.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: