Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There have been some pretty spectacular oil rig disasters with huge oil spills and >100 direct deaths. I would count those on the same scale. And those are in addition to the huge numbers of deaths every year and the contribution to global warming.


I wouldn't, though, because they don't have the impact on the population at large and don't cost nearly as much. Yes, maybe they impact other industries or recreation in an area for awhile.


Yes, it's estimated Fukushima will cost a little over double you're worst oil spill. https://theconversation.com/five-years-after-fukushima-there...

But we happily live with oil drilling and transport.

Countries like France show how safe nuclear can be.


A fossil fuel plant operating nominally without any incidents will impact the entire population as the fossil fuels are consumed and the byproducts of their combustion emitted. The number of QALYs / DALYs / deaths lost that are directly attributable to air pollution is absolutely staggering.

The magnitude of the risks we're contemplating when we're discussing nuclear are completely insignificant in relation to that.


Yes, "Yes, fossil fuels may be worse per unit of energy generated, but they are never quite this spectacular in a single event."




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: