Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Bitcoin is ALL market sentiment / vaporware / belief.

Sure, but if you take minute to think about it, so are iPhones.

They sell because people want them.

Supply and demand.

You are then going to tell me about utility.

I claim that:

    a) utility is just another way to describe demand
    b) cryptos do have utility:
        - shielding wealth from govt
        - shielding wealth from inflation
        - shielding wealth from disgruntled spouses
        - moving large quantities of wealth quickly across borders
You might or might now agree with the "morality" of these attributes, but that's neither here nor there: when it comes to economic utility, that's not really a part of the conversation.


Personally I am pulling back on the inflation claim. Im not sure that the claim that bitcoin is an inflation hedge is accurate. Or at least I haven't investigated it enough to continue advocating that claim.

I'm also not sure that bitcoin does shield wealth from government, at least in the US it doesn't. It certainly does a better job if your government is not the US. The other two claims I agree with.

To me the utility of btc is simple. It's the ability to opt into a different and codified monetary policy. That policy is collectively securitized. If I don't agree with the monetary policy of a or any government I can opt I to a system outside of that. Imo this serves as competition to centralized banking.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: