Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> If one was raised in a patriarchal setup, maybe. But some societies have already a third or even fifth generation that never knew this.

Yes, exactly! We can already observe the effects through such metrics as marriage rate and birth rate in e.g. Germany or South Korea.

> The extinction of a world view in which gender equality is considered a "sociological experiment"?

I sense some negativity, could I have formulated it in a more neutral way? Any historically new social reform e.g. tax-payer-funded health care or tuition is in a way an experiment. Also I am not sure we will ever achieve true gender equality. For example in prison population to name one metric.



Women supposedly murder 1/10th the amount of people men do.


Without context, this is just like saying that people of certain color are responsible for most crimes committed in the country etc.

I once had a friend who slapped his wife in the face once. I was shocked when I learned about this. He was very ashamed and explained that he felt completely powerless, she was shaming him he is not a real man because he earns so little and one day he broken down and - not being able to defend himself verbally - he nervously slapped her. This whole event made me sad. It's not like I justify his action, it's clear what he did was wrong and he knew this well, but cases like these get into statistics and then people make up all kinds of uninformed conclusions.


Is this because women are especially virtuous or is there something else going on?


> Yes, exactly! We can already observe the effects through such metrics as marriage rate and birth rate in e.g. Germany or South Korea.

I am missing the proof of causation here. One can equally assume that a good social safety net reduces demand to have children as providers in old age. Or that access to higher education for women lets them make a) more informed decisions or b) not rely on a male partner to provide for them.

> I sense some negativity, could I have formulated it in a more neutral way?

You could have shown that your causation is actually that, not just a correlation :)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: