Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Greenwald is not known for publishing "garbage pieces".

Reputation trails actions. Overall Greenwald seems like a remarkably average journalist with strong rhetorical chops who lucked into a couple good stories. But he's spent the past few years squandering that social capital on a mix of conspiracy and irrelevance, and this may be his bankruptcy.

> He gave up his career as a lawyer to do what he does.

This means absolutely nothing. If anything lawyers aren't especially known as paragons of truth! (And that's fine for a lawyer where the adversarial system holds, but can make you a bit shit as a journalist.)



> Greenwald seems like a remarkably average journalist

Sure, bud. Greenwald, a Pulitzer Prize winning journalist is all of a sudden "average", just because he dared to ask questions and expose near-airtight censorship by mass media and Big Tech.

https://www.newsweek.com/glenn-greenwald-legendary-progressi...


OK - and the NYT has won six Pulitzers this year. Every news organization that choose not to run the story has a dozen.

Your seemingly single criterion for trust still doesn't give the weight to Greenwald.

Mediocre people win prizes, and smart people do dumb things. Greenwald is not a reliable person to carry the entire institution of journalism on his shoulders as you keep insisting he does.

(Newsweek, by the way, has been owned and operated by Olivet / David Jang's Community cult for several years now. It has no connection to the previous magazine of the same name.)


There's a difference. Greenwald won a Pulitzer _before_ it was awarded for "orange man bad" as a sole qualification.


Thanks god we have you to properly award the Metapulitzer or we’d never know what was decent journalism.


I think the point is that a self-interested/amoral person would be unlikely to leave a career as a lawyer to become a journalist.

I'm not sure I'm entirely convinced by this. some people value influence more than money.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: