Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Typically speaking, if you're mining rocks, that's a quarry. The article also suggests using waste from steel and cement manufacturing, which is crazy.


The article also suggests using waste from steel and cement manufacturing, which is crazy.

<citation required>

If the production process is happening anyway, and if the waste exists anyway, why is it definedly crazy to re-purpose it? It isn't neccessarily the best at scale economic source of the kinds of rock dust we need, but if you have it, and it worked, then (without citing specifics like cross contamination risks or at scale problems) why is this specifically more crazy than the idea itself?


Putting industrial waste onto food, bad, bad idea. Look into the amount of contaminants in former steel mill sites.


If not rocks, what is it that mines dig out of the bedrock? What's bad about the wastes from steel and cement production?


Rock is not all made of the same thing. You don't want to put an arsenic-rich rock on farms, for example.


sounds like biomass green hand wave all over again




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: