Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I3 is a terrible wm for floating windows. Floating functionality is very primitive. No snapping. Resizing relies on hitting a small target unless you also know you can do super+shift+right click and drag. Directional bindings to switch windows doesn't work between floating windows or between floating windows and tiled ones. You have to hit a binding to go between tiled/floating. No alt tabbing between floating windows. No minimize. Scratchpad can be used for something LIKE minimize but it isn't minimize because a minimized window remains available to be recalled via an icon or label in the taskbar whereas a scratchpad window requires you to recall it by its criteria programmically or by cycling through candidates. Floating windows always overlap tiled windows so that if you have both you must relocate floating windows if you want to access tiled ones.

Floating windows in i3 are for dialog windows not applications. If you try to use it as a floating wm you would be disappointed.



That's one of the reasons why I switched from i3 to CWM. I find that I more often than not prefer floating windows to tiling.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: