Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That's not true, red light cameras have no problem issuing fines to the vehicle owner.


In many places red light cameras ticket the owner of the vehicle as a parking violation,(presumably for having you car in the intersection when the light was red?) whereas typically the driver of the vehicle is ticketed by the officer for a moving violation like speeding or running a light. My memory on this is pretty old though, laws may have changed and it may be location dependent.


Which is why they're a terrible idea, usually implemented out of sheer greed for passive income with no actual police work.


Not to mention the increase in accidents, which it'd be ironic were there a class action lawsuit holding ATS, Redflex and the other companies responsible.


Yes, but they take a picture of the car.

What if you car is being toed by a speeding truck (or on a trailer) ?


Then you could dispute the ticket, and presumably the fact that it's being towed would be visible in the photo.


There is usually a picture of the car along with a time and date of the incident. You would just simply appeal it and say that the car is clearly on a trailer and that the truck pulling the trailer is at fault.


Yes they do. In many jurisdictions, if you are willing to perjure yourself (or are innocent), you can sign an affidavit that you were not driving the vehicle. Then it is up to the authorities to press the case based on quality of the video evidence.

IMO it's a silly hack. The fine should go the vehicle owner, who is responsible for pursuing recompense from the person the lent the car to (or file a theft report, or whatever).


Yeah, in our city a few years ago, a lawsuit was brought that even with camera pictures/video, it can't be proven the vehicle owner was driving the car and so all the red light camera tickets in process were thrown out and the cameras were deactivated. So definitely depends on jurisdiction.


May I ask what city you live in?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: