Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Nonsense. People do it all the time. No judge is going to think you’re an idiot for signing some meaningless waiver that millions of other people do.


If you think that's true then you haven't seen many judges.

Other party: Did you read it before you signed it?

You: No

Other party: Why not

You: Nobody ever reads these things

Other party + Judge: :/


A better one is to insist you have not seen the document and have been forced to sign it to consent to a procedure that was time limited.

Now the onus is on the defense to show that it is not a common practice and who was responsible for that. Pretty excellent line to pursuit, hard to defend.


And easily dismissed when the defendant says "we showed him the document when he signed it. We show it to everyone" and now the onus is on prosecution to prove it.

The onus is not on the one who says it the loudest, it's on the one who can provide proof. The defense can explain to the judge that they turn the screen to show it or whatever it's supposed to do.


A contract signed under duress is not a valid contract.

There's no reason that the provider's testimony is magically preferred over the patient's, and in fact the generaly pratice is to resolve ambiguities in favor of the person who did not write the contract and is not the professional who has had plenty of pratice to know what they should be doing.


And how would they provide proof they showed it to you?


The signature is the proof!


Even Judges of the Court of Appeals don't read it: https://abovethelaw.com/2010/06/do-lawyers-actaully-read-boi...


he may rule against you but he's not going to think you're an idiot.

(We're talking about boilerplate forms here for doctor's visits, not like your mortgage)


You: Other party refused to show it to me Other party: :O


I doubt the other party would admit to that.

When it comes to he said she said you need actual evidence. The judge generally weighs what's said between both parties equally unless there's a reason not to.


Me: That's not my signature, your honor, that's a doodle I made to protest the absurdity of asking me to blindly sign something.


Key thing: Unenforceable clauses aren't enforceable.


They may not think you’re an idiot, but your signature on a contract is prima facie evidence that you assented to it.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: