Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | silverforgotapw's commentslogin

3d


You found a bug!


No one uses a. It was not a 2.4Ghz radio and not compatible with the b/g/n/ac cards that came after it.


I don't think this is true - AFAIK most 5Ghz hardware supports 802.11a.


While only anecdata, I've got a 5Ghz router and 802.11a is not an option (but 802.11b is).


New base stations don't typically have options for 11a-only 5 GHz, but 5 GHz capable 11n clients can still connect to older 5 GHz 11a networks. I imagine there is similar backwards compatibility to the other direction even without an explicit configuration option.


Wow, so much doubt. I'd normally link Wikipedia, but this is HN so let's just quote the spec to clear this up once and for all.

Legend:

PHY: think of this as "wifi radio"

HT: "High Throughput" aka 802.11n

"Clause 20": HT PHY specification

"Clause 19": 802.11g PHY specification

"Clause 18": 802.11a PHY specification

"Clause 17": 802.11b PHY specification

STA: any 802.11 capable device

[[[

20.1.1 Introduction to the HT PHY

Clause 20 specifies the PHY entity for a high throughput (HT) orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM) system.

In addition to the requirements found in Clause 20, an HT STA shall be capable of transmitting and receiving frames that are compliant with the mandatory PHY specifications defined as follows:

— In Clause 18 when the HT STA is operating in a 20 MHz channel width in the 5 GHz band

— In Clause 17 and Clause 19 when the HT STA is operating in a 20 MHz channel width in the 2.4 GHz band

]]]

Translation: All of 11a/b/g are a proper subset of 11n.

11ac is 5GHz only. I assume it's backwards compatible to 11a but I haven't read the 11ac spec.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: