Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | eochaid's commentslogin

New things are hard to value.

> When the flush of a new-born sun fell first on Eden’s green and gold,

> Our father Adam sat under the Tree and scratched with a stick in the mould;

> And the first rude sketch that the world had seen was joy to his mighty heart,

> Till the Devil whispered behind the leaves: ‘It’s pretty, but is it Art?’

— Rudyard Kipling, The Conundrum of the Workshops [1]

[1] https://poets.org/poem/conundrum-workshops


It's really hard to say exactly how this will land with fans. The article mentions using kishōtenketsu in the game design of the Grand Prix mode, "now players have to drive to their next race, instead of being automatically transported", and the wiki page for kishōtenketsu mentions use of that concept in game design of Super Mario Galaxy and Super Mario 3D World, both well received with 97 and 93 Metacritic scores respectively.

I'm sure Nintendo has put a lot of thought and effort into this. But personally I feel like most open worlds feel empty and void to me after a few hours. I didn’t play it, but that seemed to be a major complaint with the latest Pokemon game.


There's Burnout Paradise (2008) and The Crew (2014) as prior art [0,1]. And to a lesser extent GTA 1 (1997) and Crazy Taxi (1999).

I'd be more surprised if the team manages to fuck it up, given Nintendo development's solid litmus test of "what's fun and not."

A more detailed interview with the dev team seems to be available here: https://www.nintendo.com/us/whatsnew/ask-the-developer-vol-1... and https://www.nintendo.com/us/whatsnew/ask-the-developer-vol-1... and https://www.nintendo.com/us/whatsnew/ask-the-developer-vol-1... and https://www.nintendo.com/us/whatsnew/ask-the-developer-vol-1...

Regardless, verdict will be reached in a couple days!

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burnout_Paradise

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Crew_(video_game)


Super Mario Galaxy is my personal choice for best video game ever met. So, if they did it before then maybe they could do it again.

I thought after Super Mario Galaxy 2 that surely Nintendo couldn't meet that mark every again. And then Odyssey came out.


Did you play Xenoblade Chronicles X on the WiiU?

That was the open world game to me, it never felt boring (although the game itself had a lot of grind) and, if memory serves me right, about 400 square km to explore.

I sunk about 300 hours in it…

…and wish they already would release X 2.


> and wish they already would release X 2

Wouldn't that be Xenoblade Chronicles 2 & 3? Or are they too different? (I only played Xenoblade Chronicles 1, so I'm asking honestly)


No, X is a completely different story arc, setting etc...

But yes, those mentioned are great in their own right - it is just that very different setting, the real open world, game play mechanics, skells (mechs) that can take you anywhere...


Sounds similar to Mario Wonder as well, where basically the world map is playable with stuff to do and find. I think I see what they're going for now. Probably some collectables, stunts, hidden levels, etc.


This is a fun concept, and I love the name!

I’m curious why you didn’t use multiple choice for the exercises? I feel like those would be easier than typing out full answers and be closer to MOOC style homework. Maybe have a longer written question at the end of a section.

The exercises work pretty well, I like the highlighting red wrong vs. green right. It does feel a bit like the MOOC-style discussions. The tutor doesn’t just tell you the answers which is cool, but something about talking with the tutor feels a bit flat. And the flashcards weren’t very helpful for the course I picked.

I could see myself doing some courses like this with some more gamification. Being able to filter by course provider (Ycombinator, or MIT) would be cool too.


Thanks! We do have multiple choice questions now (agreed) but some of the older courses were generated when there were only short answer.

Anything specific we could improve about talking to the tutor? Definitely will add some of those features and gamify better.


Maybe give the tutor some personality or persona (having it speak as the instructor). I’m probably off base with that suggestion, though.

Again, very cool idea. I'm going to try some of the nuclear courses later this week.

Best of luck!


Please don't, or at least don't without a looooooooooot of behind-closed-doors trial and error. There are few things more off-putting then an AI try-hard "i am a quirky hooman with quirky hooman personality traits".


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: