Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | catwoe's commentslogin

I guess it's a matter of whether you own your hardware (and included software) or just own the hardware and a license to use the software that comes with it in a certain way.


I honestly cannot wrap my head around the need for an LLC. It's an open source project, why would you need a company?


IANAL, but if there's a risk of being sued by a big corporation because you're making a product that they believe is stealing from them, wouldn't it make sense to shield yourself personally from being sued?

Like, if I write a piece of software that does something innocuous, such as indexing files or something, then I probably wouldn't bother getting any kind of LLC, but I'm very unlikely to get sued over that. Nintendo, however, is famously litigious, has made their stance on emulation very clear, and has no problem going after individuals who dare to defy them. I think doing all the development through an LLC can limit Nintendo going after the individuals.


Open Source doesn't necessarily mean free of charge, but even when it does (most of the time), plenty of people still choose to pay for open source products today (eg. Red Hat). A product being open source doesn't mean the people working on it shouldn't be paid somehow; in particular, Yuzu do early releases and other closed-source-ish things (which is one of the reasons Nintendo is able to bring something to court here).


If you’re accepting money somewhere, an LLC has potential advantages. It’s not an outlandish idea at all.


Why do you need an LLC to run an emulator project?


So when it gets sued you have some protection personally. But doing crime with the LLC probably "pierces the veil" to some extent. IANAL.


They probably forsaw this coming and wanted protection in case of a lawsuit.


I like what I see but my 4 year old LG V30 still ticks all the boxes (speedy, 3.5mm, microSD and a whole lot more).

I hope I dont have to get a new phone anytime soon.


How did you validate the AnExplorer idea? What is it that makes this app unique among all the alternatives that exist? Thanks and congrats


How can you access "Press the Red button" content on a dumb TV though? Is there a software client that can access the content over http?

edit: I believe it's called HbbTV


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: